The ROBES (Resilience of benthic communities to the effects of sedimentation) programme is funded by MBIE and runs from 2016 to 2021. The project involves a strong multidisciplinary team of scientists from NIWA, Victoria University of Wellington and the University of Waikato. It also links with European research initiatives.
Currently the effects of sedimentation on life in and on the deep-seabed are not well understood.
This programme looks at the impacts of sediment plumes (clouds of sand and other particles) created by disturbance to the seafloor and the discharge of processed waters. Understanding such impacts in the deep ocean is challenging but is important for evaluating the effects on the environment of human activities and developing options to manage them.
The science approach
The research combines field survey experimentation and in situ observations with laboratory-based experiments. This complementary approach will provide information on the concentrations and distances over which impacts of suspended sediment on faunal communities become ‘ecologically significant’. The work is designed to determine the extent and persistence of sediment plumes, the immediate impact and subsequent recovery of the seafloor environment exposed to these plumes, and effects of suspended and settled sediment effects on the functioning of ecologically significant species.
Field work at sea
The field work began with a benthic disturbance survey in May-June 2018 on the Chatham Rise using NIWA’s research vessel Tangaroa. Subsequently a further two monitoring surveys were carried out in 2019 and 2020 in the same area.
On each voyage the effects on the animal community structure at the disturbance site and at increasing distances from the area of impact were examined by pre-and post-disturbance sampling using shipboard and moored instrumentation (including landers with sediment traps and optical sensors), sediment cores, and seafloor imagery. Baseline data were collected on bathymetry, topography, water column characteristics (using the vessel sensors, moored current profilers, and an underwater glider), sediment composition, and faunal community structure and abundance prior to disturbance, and then up to three times post-disturbance. Experimental work on the properties of sediment cores was also carried out in onboard laboratories.
In the laboratory
The laboratory-based side of the programme has involved holding live deep-sea corals and sponges in tanks and exposing them to various levels and durations of suspended particle loads in the water to try and identify acute and lethal thresholds as well as chronic effects of suspended sediment. Techniques were developed in an associated project as part of the Sustainable Seas National Science Challenge. The responses measured included physical impacts, feeding and respiration efficiency, behaviour and physiological responses such as mucous production. This laboratory work began in the work in 2019 with samples also collected on the third survey.
The three Voyage Reports and the Information Flyers at the end of this page describe the research surveys and some provisional results to date.
The survey area (white box) on the Chatham Rise and approximate voyage track 2020 (yellow line) at depths of at depths of 400-500 m. The survey area was the same as covered in 2018 and 2019. Grey hatched areas are Benthic Protection Areas. [NIWA]
The sampling sites (MON, DIS, REF) for camera (red) and multicorer (green) from 2018, repeated in 2019 [NIWA]
Map of sampling stations in the main survey area 2020. Codes refer to: BEAM=beam trawl, CAM=DTIS towed camera system, CPR=continuous plankton recorder, CTD=conductivity-temperature-depth probe, MOOR=mooring, MUC=multicorer, TOPAS=sub-bottom profiler. [NIWA]
The physical disturbance in the 2018 survey was carried out with a “Benthic Disturber” designed by NOAA in the USA in the 1990s and used previously in 6 disturbance surveys in the eastern Pacific Ocean. The benthic disturber did not cope well with the heavy sandy/silty sediment on the Chatham Rise compared with abyssal muds, and so in 2019 a modified tyne harrow plough (called SCIP: Sediment Cloud Induction Plough) was used.
Benthic disturber 2018 (left), Sediment Cloud Induction Plough - SCIP used in 2019 (middle) and Deep Towed Imaging System - DTIS (right). [NIWA]
Images of the: sediment plume generated by SCIP (left), and disturbed bottom sediment (right). [NIWA]
Benthic Lander: Our benthic landers carry a variety of instrumentation including an Acoustic doppler current profiler, Turbidity sensors, Temperature-salinity-dissolved oxygen sensor, Camera and light, Niskin water bottle (5 litre), and Sediment trap to measure particle deposition. [NIWA]
Samples for aquaria study species: deep-sea stony branching coral Goniocorella dumosa (left); deep-sea sea sponge Ecionemia novaezelandiae (middle), and a seafloor image of a coral community in situ (right, from DTIS). [NIWA]
Corals transferred from the catch into aquaria onboard the ship (left) and the MEMF facility at NIWA in Wellington (right). [NIWA]
Experimental chambers in the MEMF showing a gradient in suspended sediment concentrations. [Malcolm Clark, NIWA]
A demonstration of deep-sea stony branching coral larvae Goniocorella dumosa movement: beating cilia with internal mesenteries visible. Observed 17 September 2020. [NIWA]
A demonstration of deep-sea stony branching coral larvae Goniocorella dumosa directional swimming movement. Observed 17 September 2020. [NIWA]
Download: A dataset of the deep-sea stony branching coral larvae Goniocorella dumosa observations [XLS 27 KB]
Engagement with Māori
Communication with tangata whenua is integral to this research programme.
Facilitated by NIWA’s Te Kūwaha (National Centre of Māori Environmental Research) Group, the project Leader Malcolm Clark and NIWA Pou Ārahi Lee Rauhina-August visited Wharekauri/Rēkohu/Chatham Islands in 2018 and again in 2019 with NIWA scientist Joanne O’Callaghan to outline the project, methodology and opportunities for tangata whenua to be involved in this research.
Meetings were also held with Ngāi Tahu. Such hui and information exchange using flyers (see below) help researchers better understand the viewpoints and concerns of Māori and this engagement is on-going.
As a result of these interactions, two tangata whenua representatives participated in the survey that took place in June 2019.
An important aspect of the programme’s partnership with tangata whenua on the 2019 voyage was the participation of Apirana Daymond representing Te Aitanga o ngā uri o Wharekauri (left), and Cassidy Solomon representing Hokotehi Moriori Trust (right). [NIWA]
ROBES End-users webinar, 30 June 2022 - presentations & recording
Sedimentation Research Webinar participants at Greta Point June 30 2022: Back row L to R: Di Tracey, Charine Collins, Apirana Daymond, Mike Williams, Malcolm Clark, Ashley Rowden, Scott Nodder, Joshu Mountjoy, Pascal Otis, Joe O'Callaghan. Front row Te Aitanga o ngā Uri o Wharekauri – Rod Daymond, Ko Daymond, Jack Daymond holding a model of the glider), Lee Rauhina-August. [Photo: Lana Young, NIWA]
The research programme also has a user advisory group that provides feedback on the research and ensures the work remains relevant for application to stakeholders. The group has representatives from government agencies, the fishing industry, a commercial mining company, the minerals industry, an environmental group and the research team.
ROBES Voyage Report 2 Nov 2019 [PDF 6.1MB]
Robes Voyage Report 3 March 2021 [PDF 7MB]
Information Flyer April 2019 [PDF 448 KB]
Information Flyer August 2018 [PDF 200KB]
Information Flyer September 2018 [PDF 200KB]
Information Flyer No 4 - engagement 20 Nov 2019 [PDF 500KB]
Information Flyer No 5 - 20 Nov 2019 [PDF 378KB]
Information Flyer No 6 - 1 Mar 2020 [PDF 370KB]
Information Flyer No 7 - 22 June 2020 [PDF 450 KB]
Information Flyer No 8 - 22 June 2020 [PDF 350KB]
Information Flyer No 9 - 23 March 2021 [PDF 277KB]
Information Flyer No 10 - June 2021 [PDF270KB]
Information Flyer No 11 - Mar 2022 [PDF300KB]
Sea-floor species health and survival to underwater 'sediment clouds'. Webinar presented to Sustainable Seas National Science Challenge, 27 August 2020. Clark, M.R., Cummings, V., Beaumont, J., Mobilia, V., Bell, J., Barr, N., Tracey, D., McGrath, E. (2020). [PDF 10MB]
Dynamic seafloor processes within the Subtropical Frontal Zone on the Chatham Rise and implications for regional sediment and organic carbon budgets. Nodder, S., Clark, M., O’Callaghan, J., Leduc, D., Hickey, C., Rowden, A., Eager, C., Hale, R., Gerrin, P., Price, O., Elliott, F., Searson, S., Deppeler, S., Frontin-Rollet, G., Ovenden, R. , Christchurch, New Zealand, November 2020. [PDF 2.1MB]
Ecotoxicity and Biogeochemical assessment of deep-sea mine sediments. SETAC. Darwin, Australia. July 2019. Hickey, C.W., Frontin-Rollet, G., Eager, C., Handler, M., Wysoczanski, R.J. (2019). [PDF 3.3MB]
External People Involved
James Bell – Victoria University of Wellington
Valeria Mobilia - Victoria University of Wellington
Chris Eager - Waikato Regional Council
Chris Hickey - Consultancy Firm
Conrad Pilditch – University of Waikato
Campbell Murray -- Fisheries New Zealand FNZ
Free phone within New Zealand: 0800 RING NIWA (0800 746 464)